
Click for more after the jump...
While the visual effects could never look more real and wonderful, they simply don't add much to the picture. The same goes for the Brian Eno score, which at times seems overly sentimental in combination with some of Jackson's tear-baiting scenes. While I'm unfamiliar with the source material, the script seems a bit confusing at times, for spoiler purposes I'll leave the details out. Jackson's use of horror and chills also has a difficult time balancing themselves out with the films humor and mawkishness.
Where Jackson does excel is in his use of pace and tension to bring the simplest of scenes to an edge-of-your-seat thriller. This is also aided in part by the magnificent turn from America's favorite supporting actor, Stanley Tucci. Never has such an affable and friendly face been made to seem as menacing and creepy as Tucci in the role of Susie's disturbed neighbor Mr. Harvey.
Saoirse Ronan also brings spectacular life to Susie as the wide-eyed 14-year-old. The rest of the cast is filled out with excellent turns from Susan Sarandon, Rachel Weisz, and good Mark Wahlberg (as opposed to bad Mark Wahlberg who shows up to work sometimes).
It's just a shame all these parts couldn't add up to more. While Jackson has a deft eye when it comes to directing, and he steers his cast true, he should have toned down on the grand visual effects and sentimentality.
--Greg MacLennan